Grilled Chicken Sandwich With Nothing to Hide
Jump to recipe ↓
It is 12:45 on a Saturday, the grill is hot, and the whole plan fits on one hand: chicken, bun, lettuce, tomato. This grilled chicken sandwich takes about 15 minutes of real work, six minutes a side over the heat, and it is a sandwich with nothing to hide, which is more than we can say for your last text thread.
Salt, pepper, fire, and a tomato slice thick enough to have an opinion.
There is no marinade and no sauce. You season two chicken breasts with salt and pepper, grill them six minutes a side, toast the buns for a minute at the end, and stack lettuce, tomato and chicken. This grilled chicken sandwich is simple on purpose, and the grill does the flirting.
What you need
- 2 chicken breasts
- 2 hamburger buns
- 4 leaf lettuce leaves
- 1 tomato
- ¼ tsp salt
- ¼ tsp black pepper
How to make it
- Slice the 1 large tomato, about 2 minutes.
- Season the 2 chicken breasts with salt and black pepper.
- Grill the chicken breasts for 6 minutes per side until cooked through.
- Toast the 2 hamburger buns on the grill for 1 minute.
- Layer the 4 leaves lettuce and tomato slices on the bottom buns.
- Add the grilled chicken and top with the buns.
Notes
Cooked leftovers keep three to four days refrigerated, per USDA FSIS. Store the chicken on its own and build the sandwich fresh. A bun that has been sitting against a warm tomato goes soft quickly, so keep the parts separate until you are ready.
Leftover grilled chicken is good cold and sliced thin, or warmed gently in a skillet. It also freezes fine on its own if you wrap it well and label the bag, but the lettuce, tomato and bun do not belong in the freezer.
Plan the clock like this: a couple of minutes to slice the tomato, six minutes a side on the grill, a minute to toast the buns, and a short rest for the chicken before you stack it. Slice the tomato while the first side cooks and the rest takes care of itself.
Chicken breasts vary a lot in thickness, and thick ones take longer than thin ones. Six minutes a side is the plan, and a thick breast may need a few more.
Rest the chicken for a few minutes before you slice or stack it. The juices settle back into the meat, and the sandwich stays together instead of sliding apart.
A thick breast and a bun do not always get along. If one of your breasts is much thicker at one end, shift it on the grill so the thin end sits on a cooler spot, and turn the pair at the six minute mark. Both pieces should end up cooked through at about the same time.
Swaps that actually work
The chicken breast and the grill are the point of a grilled chicken sandwich. Without the char, you are eating a plain boiled breast on a bun, and the whole sandwich depends on the smoky surface.
The list is short, so the biggest improvements are in what you add. A slice of cheddar laid on the chicken for the last minute, a spoon of mayonnaise or mustard on the bun, and a few pickle slices all fit. A slice of cheddar and toasted bread both work.
Hamburger buns can be swapped for brioche, ciabatta or sandwich bread. A sturdier bread handles a juicy chicken breast better than a soft one, and it holds up to the tomato. Swipe this one into your week and the agent puts the buns and the tomato in the cart, so the only thing left to forget is the propane.
Chicken thighs work as well, and they are more forgiving if you are watching the grill with one eye on a conversation.
If you have no grill, a grill pan or a hot skillet will do. You will not get the same smoke, but you will get the browned surface that matters.
The swap that costs you the dish is skipping the salt. With so few ingredients, the seasoning on the chicken is carrying the whole sandwich.
If it goes wrong
The chicken is dry. It cooked too long, or the breast was very thick and cooked unevenly. Pull it at 165°F, rest it, and slice it across the grain. If it has already dried out, add a slice of cheese, a spoon of mayonnaise or a wet tomato slice to bring moisture back.
It is burned outside and pink inside. The grill was too hot for a thick breast. Move the chicken to a cooler part, close the lid if you have one, and give it a few more minutes. Next time, slice a very thick breast horizontally so it cooks evenly.
The bun is soggy. The tomato or hot chicken sat against it. Toast the bun for the full minute, and put the lettuce between the bun and the tomato to act as a barrier.
It tastes flat. If it tastes flat, it is probably salt. Season the breast on both sides before it hits the heat, and add a pinch more to the tomato slice.
What to serve with it
The default for a grilled chicken sandwich is the sandwich on its own, with chips or fruit if it is a casual lunch.
The better version of the default is a quick slaw or a handful of dressed greens on the side. A grilled chicken sandwich is dry and savory, and something cool and tangy balances it.
The thing in the fridge that lifts it is a sauce. Mayonnaise, mustard, hot sauce or a spoon of pesto turns a plain chicken sandwich into something with an angle.
It makes a good packed lunch if you slice the chicken and pack the bun, lettuce and tomato separately.
Why this one earns its place
Some dinners ask you to be clever, and this one asks you to turn on the grill and pay attention for twelve minutes. That is a fair deal for a weekend lunch, and it leaves room for the sauce, the cheese or the side you decide to add.
When you swipe it into your week, the agent shops the chicken, the buns and the tomato, so the only decision left is which side to cook first. For more on keeping lunches simple, read quick weeknight dinner ideas. Then see fried chicken sandwich for the crispy version, and bbq chicken wraps for another handheld.
More like this: all American recipes in Crave Corner.